Devesh
Core Member
Sushil Kumar won't be able to compete at the Rio Olympics. Delhi High Court dismissed the star wrestler's plea for a trial in the 74kg category, paving way for Narsingh Yadav's participation in the quadrennial event.
Sushil moved court in the hope of getting a trial against Narsingh Yadav, the quota place winner. But Delhi High Court, in its verdict on Monday, dismissed Sushil's plea for a trial. Hence, Sushil's hopes got dashed.
Delhi High Court gave two reasons for the dismissal of Sushil's petition.
First, the court felt that with little time left for the Olympics, holding trial would hamper the possibility of winning a medal at Olympics. The prospect of injury could not be ruled out, according to Wrestling Federation of India's lawyer.
The court also added that Narsingh secured the berth for India by winning a bronze medal in 74kg at the World Championship. So, he is a natural player since inception in the 74kg.
The Delhi High Court, in its last hearing on Thursday, gave clear indications that it was likely to give a judgement in favour of the Wrestling Federation of India (WFI) in the tiff over selection trials in the men's 74kg freestyle category.
The Delhi High court had observed that it did not find "any statutory mandate" to hold trials before the Olympics.
"Problem is that the sports code is nowhere prescribing that trial is mandatory. It has given flexibility and autonomy to the organisation to decide (mode of selection). I do not find the statutory mandate which you are trying to read into it," Justice Manmohan had said during the final hearing.
Narsingh - the quota place winner
Narsingh had secured the Olympic quota place for India last year at the World Championship in Las Vegas after winning a bronze medal.
Since then the Maharashtra grappler has been staking his claim for the berth and the WFI had also been steadfast in its stand to send Narsingh to Rio since he had grabbed the quota.
Going by norms in WFI guidelines, a quota belongs to the country and not to an individual wrestler, and former world champion Sushil pointed out that there should be a trial in 74kg category to decide who would go to Rio.
The 33-year-old, who had won a bronze medal in 2008 Beijing Olympics and followed it up with a silver in 2012 London Games, had moved the court seeking directions to WFI to hold selection trials.
Weight category rejig
Sushil had won both his Olympic medals in 66kg category but had to move up to 74kg after the International Wrestling body (FILA) rejigged the weight divisions post the London Games.
Sushil's climbing up to the 74kg weight category brought him in direct competition with Narsingh, who had represented India in this category in earlier Olympics.
After jumping up the division, Sushil had fought in just a couple of international tournaments. In fact, what has gone against Sushil is that he had last fought in 2014 Commonwealth Games at Glasgow, where he had won a gold medal. Since then he has not participated in any major event owing to injuries.
Before the World Championship last year, WFI had conducted trials but Sushil opted out of that as well as he sustained a shoulder injury at that time.
He also did not take part in the inaugural Pro Wrestling League, once again citing injury, in December last year.
However, Sushil kept training in the last one year and also went to Georgia for a training stint in April.
Wrestling Star Sushil Kumar's Rio Olympics Dreams Jolted After High Court Order - Olympics 2016 News
Sushil moved court in the hope of getting a trial against Narsingh Yadav, the quota place winner. But Delhi High Court, in its verdict on Monday, dismissed Sushil's plea for a trial. Hence, Sushil's hopes got dashed.
Delhi High Court gave two reasons for the dismissal of Sushil's petition.
First, the court felt that with little time left for the Olympics, holding trial would hamper the possibility of winning a medal at Olympics. The prospect of injury could not be ruled out, according to Wrestling Federation of India's lawyer.
The court also added that Narsingh secured the berth for India by winning a bronze medal in 74kg at the World Championship. So, he is a natural player since inception in the 74kg.
The Delhi High Court, in its last hearing on Thursday, gave clear indications that it was likely to give a judgement in favour of the Wrestling Federation of India (WFI) in the tiff over selection trials in the men's 74kg freestyle category.
The Delhi High court had observed that it did not find "any statutory mandate" to hold trials before the Olympics.
"Problem is that the sports code is nowhere prescribing that trial is mandatory. It has given flexibility and autonomy to the organisation to decide (mode of selection). I do not find the statutory mandate which you are trying to read into it," Justice Manmohan had said during the final hearing.
Narsingh - the quota place winner
Narsingh had secured the Olympic quota place for India last year at the World Championship in Las Vegas after winning a bronze medal.
Since then the Maharashtra grappler has been staking his claim for the berth and the WFI had also been steadfast in its stand to send Narsingh to Rio since he had grabbed the quota.
Going by norms in WFI guidelines, a quota belongs to the country and not to an individual wrestler, and former world champion Sushil pointed out that there should be a trial in 74kg category to decide who would go to Rio.
The 33-year-old, who had won a bronze medal in 2008 Beijing Olympics and followed it up with a silver in 2012 London Games, had moved the court seeking directions to WFI to hold selection trials.
Weight category rejig
Sushil had won both his Olympic medals in 66kg category but had to move up to 74kg after the International Wrestling body (FILA) rejigged the weight divisions post the London Games.
Sushil's climbing up to the 74kg weight category brought him in direct competition with Narsingh, who had represented India in this category in earlier Olympics.
After jumping up the division, Sushil had fought in just a couple of international tournaments. In fact, what has gone against Sushil is that he had last fought in 2014 Commonwealth Games at Glasgow, where he had won a gold medal. Since then he has not participated in any major event owing to injuries.
Before the World Championship last year, WFI had conducted trials but Sushil opted out of that as well as he sustained a shoulder injury at that time.
He also did not take part in the inaugural Pro Wrestling League, once again citing injury, in December last year.
However, Sushil kept training in the last one year and also went to Georgia for a training stint in April.
Wrestling Star Sushil Kumar's Rio Olympics Dreams Jolted After High Court Order - Olympics 2016 News
