News Net Neutrality Debate: Trai Gets 80 Percent Replies via Facebook

Technoglitch

Core Member
As Trai gears up to frame the net neutrality rules, telecom operators have favoured differential pricing for data services even as nearly 80 percent replies to the regulator's consultation process follow theFacebook 'templates' for its controversy-ridden Free Basics platform.

While net neutrality activists continue to oppose any differential pricing regime, saying it would amount to curbs on freedom of choice to access Internet, Facebook has launched a massive campaign to project its Free Basics platform as a tool to spread web connectivity.

An analysis of a record 2.4 million comments, received by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) to its consultation paper on differential pricing for data services, shows that 1.894 million replies are in support of Free Basics, of which 1.35 million views are through '@supportfreebasics.in' and without the senders' individual e-mail IDs while further 544,000 comments have come from '@facebookmail.com'.

On the other hand, the net neutrality campaigners have submitted 4.84 lakh comments through forums like 'Save the Internet'.

Besides, there are comments from telecom and Internet service providers, industry bodies and individuals. The telecom operators including Airtel, Vodafone, Idea, Reliance Communications and their respective associations have supported differential pricing for data services, while Internet service providers have opposed the plan.

"For the growth of data service, price differentiation for data services can be allowed," operators have submitted.

Facebook’s Chris Cox in India

Another meeting and yet another desperate attempt at selling Free Basics aka death of net neutrality in India. Late last week, some of our sources were hinting at a Facebook product-related executive visiting India to meet some company founders in Bengaluru. Now, a new report by The Times of India, states that the company’s chief product officer Chris Cox will be in New Delhi to further gather support for its Free Basics initiative.

The report adds that a round table has been scheduled with about 30 entrepreneurs including founders of Paytm, Practo and Limeroad. The discussion is around how to spruce up or reshape tech products and related experience, but Free Basics is also one of the topics to be discussed.

Facebook's Chris Cox in India; another desperate attempt to sell Free Basics – Tech2
 

timkamat

EntMnt Ambassador
Finest Member
Thats because facebook has been aggressively advertising and lobbying for free basics on its apps. Even I have been consistently getting the pop up. Most of the users using facebook do nit have in depth knowledge of net neutrality and they just click on send now.
 

timkamat

EntMnt Ambassador
Finest Member
In fact action needs to be taken against them. Most if the ppl using facebook do not have enough know how and they are the ones who fall prey to such propaganda.
 

Technoglitch

Core Member
The deadline set by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) for receiving public opinions/suggestions on its consultation paper on Net Neutrality expired on 7 January. To be fair to the Trai, it did not seek expert view on Net Neutrality as such, but ‘on a specific matter of differential policy for data services being offered by the operators’. Nevertheless this ‘specific matter’ is an integral and important part of the Net Neutrality debate.

Unfortunately, the specific consultation process initiated by the Trai was hijacked by the Free Basics debate involving Facebook. As per reports, by 7 January when the deadline expired, Trai had received almost 24 lakh responses out of which 13.5 lakh came through the template of ‘@supportfreebasics.in’ without individual emails and 5.44 lakh comments came along the same lines through ‘@facebookmail.com”.

The major chunk of the opposite view, which countered the Free Basics proposition, came through another template ‘Save the Internet’. It attracted 4.84 lakh responses.

Net Neutrality debate: Will India end up going the way of the US? - Firstpost
 

Aviral Sangal

EntMnt Ambassador
Finest Member
All the votes from virtual ids or same ids should be considered null and void. And they should be penalised for spamming and cheating customers. TRAI had only asked for suggestions through email. What they did was anyone giving a missed call is also sent as a suggestion.
 
Top