EntMnt Xclusive Report of the CAG on Management of Satellite Capacity for DTH Service by Department of Space

[DashMajor]

Pls don't share anyone's personal ID here. If someone want give him in PC.

Is the following id is personal ? I saw that id in Nagpal's twitter handle too.

 

[aumnamonarayan]

Pls don't share anyone's personal ID here. If someone want give him in PC.

Bro, its the company e-mail Id and not a personal one. Mr. Nagpal openly shares it on social media platforms like Twitter. Also why have u deleted the complete post in which i mentioned the ID, u could have deleted just the E-Mail ID

 

[SUNIEL]

aumnamonarayan Bro. I agree each and everything what you just say in fact I too say the same thing that GSAT 10 is not a replacement of Insat 4 A but offered as a replacement. Within 2, 3 years replacement SAT of Insat 4 A gonna launch.

But I don't think TS is any way make new space because addition of more channels will increase of content cost and this is not what TS want.

Yaar, aap dono kaisi baat kar rahein ho. They could have easily taken GSAT10 TP's plus moved all channels to MPEG4 which would have given ample bandwidth for next 2 years and in next 1 or 2 years ISRO is already slated to launch replacement satellite for Insat 4A at 83 degrees east.

Plz note, GSAT 10 was originally not a replacement satellite for Insat 4A but as its launch got delayed by more than 5 years so DOS offered it as a replacement to Tata Sky. Replacement Sat of Insat 4A will be launched in next 1 or 2 years if Tata Sky decides to stay ta same orbit and take GSAT10..

But if Tata Sky has lost faith in ISRO and decided to opt for a Foreign Satellite then its fine too but they need to take the shift soon

According to article, Gsat 10 was not replacement until March 2013 but later due inability of launched new satellite ICC and Dos taken a decision in March 2013, gsat 10 will be a replacement sat.




Beyond this I dont understand English much more so want comment from other member
.

 

[Sanjeev]

aumnamonarayan, can you please provide any source where they have mentioned that ISRO is going to launch replacement satellite for Insat 4A?

Same question from my side

 

[SUNIEL]

Again they will waste 2 - 3 years to completely moved to foreign SAT.

Bro question is not about this 2 to 3 yrs, question is about future. Everyone including we people knows how isro work. They are fail to fulfill targeted goal each time in 5 year plan despite having sufficient funding by govt. Isro more worried about mangal and moon mission so

 

[Sanjeev]

Bro question is not about this 2 to 3 yrs, question is about future. Everyone including we people knows how isro work. They are fail to fulfill targeted goal each time in 5 year plan despite having sufficient funding by govt. Isro more worried about mangal and moon mission so

Yes and because of that they neglect the issue of INSAT satellites and some or the other problem occurs while launching it so because of this carelessness and their attitude all DTH are backing away

 

[SUNIEL]

Same question from my side

No satellite in 12th Five Year Plan means till 2018, after that in 13th five year plan they will announce new sat and will launch in 2024

 

[NinadG]

There are reports that Planning Commission is being scrapped by Modi govt. If its true then what would be the impact on five year plans & on Isro missions....?

 

[NinadG]

Bro question is not about this 2 to 3 yrs, question is about future. Everyone including we people knows how isro work. They are fail to fulfill targeted goal each time in 5 year plan despite having sufficient funding by govt. Isro more worried about mangal and moon mission so

I think they want to hide their deficiencies in developing Gsat by launching moon & mars mission with the help from foreign org.

 

[NinadG]

I think everyone highlighting same why ts not move on gsat but here is fact

When gsat 10 get nod from govt in 2007 it was additional satellite in this orbit. Later it launched in 2012 successfully, everyone think same as it was scheduled additional but ICC and isro take a decision in March 2013 that Gsat 10 will be replacement of INSAT 4A that time ts agreed for swap tp (don't know why) but in April may June ts search option its not possible to get nod from govt for use of foreign sat in very short time so later ts taken decision to move on MPEG4 so denied to swap tp because they realise mpeg4 is short term solution for only next 2 and hardly 3 yrs. Again future will be dark so why not use refusal right and move on foreign sat in this 2yrs.


I don't know much English but I think I write understanding simple word.

But how many times & days TS will keep realising that they need to plan for long term?
Why it happens only with TS.......?